The Influence of Knowledge Management, Human Resource Competency, and
Work Environment on Employee Performance Moderated by Innovation at PT
Petrokimia Gresik Tri Aldiyanto Putra 1, Eva
Desembrianita 2, Rahmat Agus Santoso 3 Muhammadiyah
University Gresik,
Indonesia Email: [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected] |
Keywords |
Abstract |
Knowledge Management , Human Resources
Competency, Work Environment, Innovation, Employee Performance |
The population in Indonesia is increasing along with the need for food. The availability of fertilizer commodities as biological nutrients for agricultural needs must be increased. PT Petrokimia Gresik under the state-owned company PT Pupuk Indonesia strives to maintain employee performance in supporting the company's production to continue to grow. This research aims to determine the influence of knowledge Management , Human Resource Competency, and Work Environment on Employee Performance Moderated by Innovation at PT Petrokimia Gresik (Persero). The population in this study was 2043 Petrokimia Gresik employees, the sample in this study was 197. The sampling technique was Simple Random Sampling . Data analysis uses Smart PLS 0.3 structural model calculations. The results of this research found that Knowledge Management and Innovation do not have a direct effect on Employee Performance, HR Competency and Work Environment have a direct effect on Employee Performance, There is a positive interaction between Knowledge Management and Innovation in influencing Employee Performance. Innovation cannot moderate the interaction between HR Competency and Work Environment on Employee Performance . � 2024 by the authors. Submitted for possible open access
publication under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons
Attribution (CC BY SA) license ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ ). |
1 Introduction
State predicate embedding agrarian for Indonesia is an expression
that also proves it is a competitive business area exploration natural and tempting for perpetrator modern
business . During pandemic Covid -19 sector agriculture are required
to continue walk use fulfil need commodity principal public Indonesia . Field
business agriculture relatively always sustainable and almost No There is
receding . At a glance field agriculture in Indonesia assessed more backward
while developed countries has Lots experiment with exists technology around
moment This . However, developments technology agriculture Indonesia Actually has
develop only just still not integrated in a way technology.
Sulistyastuti
Rusdiana & Maesya
Currently, it is estimated that the amount that can be provided for
fertilizer in Indonesia is only 9 million tons or only 37% of the 24 million
tons needed by the country as a whole for fertilizer subsidies. Currently only
15 million tons of fertilizer can be produced by PT Pupuk Indonesia, with 9
million tons used for subsidies and around 6 million tons for commercial use
For a long time, high fertilizer prices have forced the government to help
in the form of subsidies to farmers. However, subsidies are gradually being
reduced so that the burden on the state does not become heavier due to the
sluggish economy since the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020. Apart from PT Petrokimia
Gresik, PT Pupuk Indonesia (Persero) also oversees other fertilizer companies
which are part of the BUMN Holding Company entity� including PT Pupuk Kujang Cikampek, PT Pupuk
Kaltim, PT Pupuk Iskandar Muda. And PT Pupuk Sriwijaya Palembang.
In the
last three years KPI Key Performance Indicator (KPI) Petrokimia Gresik continues
to increase and in the last six years has experienced fluctuations. The
Petrokimia Gresik KPI score is based on several perspectives used, including:
, there are two important things related
to performance issues, namely fulfillment stock and implementation Turn Around. Not long ago,
a government policy regarding reducing subsidized fertilizers emerged, namely
that Petrokimia Gresik's products from previously six types of fertilizer were
decided to become only two types of products, namely Urea and NPK Phonska. At
least this policy will be implemented no later than July 2022. This indicates
that the company's challenges in the future will be greater with the commercial
market share.
Of the total income before tax, the
company's profit is projected to experience a change in composition.
Previously, the total income was IDR 1.13 trillion from subsidized sales
profits, 29 percent will now experience a shift to the commercial zone. Facing
intense business competition and the need to respond to the dynamics of
government policy which periodically removes subsidies, companies need to
continuously improve their performance every year.
In connection with the phenomenon of
fertilizer as a farming need and supporting national food, fertilizer
production capabilities at Petrokimia Gresik are still in a fluctuating
position. The last 3 years are considered to have not
grown, the increase and decrease in production from 8.1 million to 7.69 million
tons, has not helped meet national needs of more than 22 million tons. This
condition is an assumption of inappropriate management regarding employee output
as the company's Human Capital .
The conditions of
the digital era have spurred the atmosphere of all businesses to accelerate,
competing to carry out digital transformation in their companies.
Each industry streamlines all production supply chain process activities.
Petrokimia Gresik is in an effort to create or renew a conventional
organizational structure into an agile system organization ( Agile
Organization ), creating competitive advantages to meet customer needs and
generate better profits for the company. Among them, downsizing or
downsizing is being carried out by many companies to achieve this goal.
Gresik Petrokimia Company is
facing efficiency amount target employees are demoted from the previous 2400 people to
1800 people on 2024 will bring challenges business where is the
subsidy? fertilizer will revoked and national fertilizer needs are still high . Known 3 years earlier in 202 0 , More of the 2,400 people treated in
competence systemic from stage recruitment until evaluation performance
employee support procedure operations and continuity business company
Petrokimia Gresik.
In line with the policy of the central company, namely PT Pupuk Indonesia,
which centralizes employee recruitment and the internal efficiency plans of
Indonesian fertilizer subsidiaries, the number of employees gradually decreases
until it reaches 1983 as of June 2022. This condition allows 2 things to
happen, namely an increase in income or benefits for employees and an increase
employee workload with the company's Business Size is still the same.
Even plans project expansion addition of new factories being developed namely ALF3, Soda A sh , And Phonska 5 as effort company increase capacity production fertilizer also requires Human Resources for the sake of , this is simply to fulfill fertilizer demand requirements
national .
Apart from downsizing, Petrokimia
Gresik is also facing waves transition from medium senior employees going to pension to employee young (Millennials and Gen Z
) as Human Resources (HR) mover , now and for decades to come as perpetrators
manufacturer business agroindustry . At least 185 employees are approaching retirement by
2027.
Performance and spirit of growth business company must be improved . Increasing competitive advantage, which is the main driver of business expansion for the entire Holding Groups are needed to support this as well as proper work capacity management . Petrokimia Gresik which is currently This has decided to evolve and grow with more markets wide . Through the company's tagline "Agroindustry Solutions". this is trying show commitment and determination in carry out business strategies new use win competition business national and global.
One of asset most important company is
Human Resources. It
was recorded that in 2021, termination of employment (PHK) caused by employees
in the category of committing disciplinary violations increased by 3 people in
a year. This condition is of great concern to the company, especially the
Remuneration and Industrial Relations department at PT Petrokimia Gresik
because the company has never experienced this incident in the last 4 years.
Gratification
or bribery is one of seven categories within the scope of complaints about
violations at Petrokimia Gresik. Compared to 2020, the number of gratuity
reports at Petrokimia Gresik has increased in 2021. This condition can indicate
two important things, one of which can explain that the fraud reporting
system has been running well in the company, on the other hand, the increase in
reports shows that recently there has been an increase in the potential for
fraud. emerging from the external and internal environment that provokes or
triggers employees to commit fraud.
Evaluation Criteria The
Superior Performance Assessment (KPKU) has become a reference for the Petrokimia Gresik company,
which is part of BUMN, in measuring social performance on employee
productivity. Letter
secretary Ministry of BUMN No.
: S-08/S.MBU/2013 dated 16 January 2013 has regulated regarding � Delivery Guidelines Determination of KPIs and Criteria Assessment of
Superior Performance in BUMN ". Below in more detail you can see seven
category measurement performance KPKU based.
Petrokimia Gresik in the
KPKU Assessment is included in the Emerging Industry Leader criteria which the company routinely carries
out every year. In the last three years, the KPKU score obtained by the company
has experienced fluctuations which can be seen in the Bar Chart image.
In Figure 12, it
can be seen that the superior performance assessment of employee productivity
has decreased in score by negative 22 in 2021 compared to the previous year
2020. Even though it is relatively small, this fact explains that there is a
problematic situation in the performance variable, especially for employees,
which can have an impact on productivity.
Six
components form management : Men, Money, Methods , Materials, Machines, and
Markets . Man Power Management or often known with Human Resource
Management or in short HRM is one branch knowledge source management
from component human ( Human ) . Where personnel management refers to controlling management
element man
Several
organizational learning activities from companies to implement Knowledge
Management within the company, starting from collecting knowledge,
converting, and applying it through Knowledge Sharing such as education
and training, Mentoring and Self Learning.
Employee
training is part of Knowledge Sharing on knowledge management. It
was recorded that there was an increase in employee training hours from 2019 to
2020 by 22 percent and from 2020 to 2021 by 16 percent. This shows that the
implementation of Knowledge Company management is running and
developing.
The graphic image above in the bar diagram shows that in the last 4 years
employee HR competency as represented by educational levels at Strata 2, Strata
1 and Diploma 3 levels has increased in terms of the proportion of the number
of employees. Meanwhile, at the high school and junior high school levels, it
decreases from year to year. However, simultaneously in the line diagram it can
be seen that the number of employees consistently decreases every year at all
levels of education.
Facing this management policy, every employee must have innovation to
contribute to streamlining processes in the company's internal business lines
so that consistent work results are achieved according to targets.
Apart from
improving HR competency, the Company is also trying to develop new products
including Phosgreen, Petro ZA Plus, Kebomas Petro Cane, Kebomas Sipedas, and
Kebomas. This innovative product is expected to be able to help companies
expand market share and later increase profitability.
In order to encourage achievement and increase performance, innovation is one of the components of company value that is consistently pursued by all business organs . It was recorded that employees involved in innovation grew 5% compared to the previous 2 years and the innovation team increased by 100 teams from the previous year. Activity innovation in the form of a company � Compartmental Level Innovation Convention � abbreviated as KIK and " Company Level Innovation Convention " abbreviated as KIPG every routine year held .
The work environment can also provide encouragement to employees to
increase knowledge.
The company strives to improve the work environment which is widely
reflected in the achievement of the Proper award every year. This award was
given by the Indonesian Ministry of Environment and Forestry to Petrokimia
Gresik as a company that carries out sustainable environmental management. It
can be seen that the results of the company's efforts regarding the environment
have increased periodically until 2021 with gold as the highest achievement.
Carbon dioxide emissions, which have become a
world issue, are increasingly difficult to control, companies play an active
role in reducing greenhouse gases. Intensity emission
referring to the Regulations Director General Control Pollution and Damage
Environment Number: P.17/PPKL/SET/KUM.1/09/2020. In reporting period 2021 is available decline
intensity of 0.007 or 4% compared year 2020 . In the last 3 years the company reduced carbon dioxide emissions by 18.8%.
This has implications for the work environment in factory production as work
areas and employee activities that are cleaner in terms of air.
Divergence from previous research,
Research
objectives This are: 1. To find out and analyze
the direct influence of Knowledge Management of Performance Employee. 2. To find out and analyze
the direct influence of Human Resource Competency on Performance Employee.
3. To find out and analyze the direct influence of the Work
Environment on Performance Employee. 4. To find out and analyze
the direct influence of Innovation on Employee Performance. 5. To find out and analyze Knowledge
relationships Management and Innovation in influencing Employee Performance . 6. To determine and analyze
the relationship between Human Resource Competency and Innovation in
influencing Employee Performance . 7. To determine and analyze
the relationship between the work environment and innovation in influencing
employee performance.
2 Materials and Methods
Design and Location
Explanation in this subchapter
regarding planning, description, types and methods of carrying out research
methods using predetermined designs. The research location is explained and
determined according to the research background where the problem lies so that
the results can then be analyzed in the next chapter.
Research on the influence of
Knowledge Management, Human Resource Competency, Work Environment,
and Employee Performance through Innovation Moderation at PT Petrokimia Gresik
by applying a quantitative approach.
Enter the
explanation of the use of types study This classified as descriptive quan tative . As for inside
study This variable covers study intensive on Knowledge Management
, Human Resources Competency , and Environment
Deep work the role of influence on employee performance
through innovation moderation .
Research is of a nature explanatory which is prepared with the aim
of
providing explanation connection causality between variable by running testing hypothesis at a
time do data
parsing .
Explanatory
planning is the process of testing hypotheses or deep theories study this is expected to be
possible
method which is
used to
find the truth connection causal one variable with variable others consisting from Variable
Knowledge
Management, Human
Resources Competency, and Internal Work Environment his role on Employee Performance with Innovation as Moderation .
Place The research was carried out at PT. Petrokimia
Gresik (Persero)
can be seen in detail in the following image information: Determining the location to be researched was based
on the researcher's consideration that there was an effort by the company to
formulate and solve problems related to employee performance, because in
internal and external analysis performance is an important benchmark for the
company's strength .
Entering sub-chapter 3.2, it describes
how the population is distributed and the criteria used if necessary for the
object to be studied. Once the population is known, we then proceed to
determine the sample. What is more specific and important is the sample size
because it is needed with the aim that the results obtained can describe the
population as a whole.
The provisions
for obtaining samples that will be used for this research implement Probability
Sampling .
After
determining the sampling technique used, the next step is to determine the
limit size of the research sample that must be taken.
3 Results and Discussions
Data analysis
After obtaining a sample of 197 respondents
from the questionnaire, during this data analysis a discussion was carried out
including analysis of respondent characteristics, descriptive research
variables, hypothesis testing, Outer Model evaluation, Inner Model
evaluation, including direct influence testing and moderating influence
testing.
A. Respondent Characteristics
To obtain details regarding the characteristics of respondents, a
frequency distribution approach was used. The steps taken include the following:
1. Determining Reach
U.maximum = largest data
U.minimal = smallest data
2. Defining Multiple Classes
K = number of classes
n = class length
3. Determining the Interval or Class Length
From this equation, the following calculation
results are obtained:
1. Largest data ������� =
Smallest Data ���� =
Reach �� =
2.
Table 1. Respondent Scales
Scale |
Years of service |
Last
education |
Position |
1 |
0 to 4 Years |
SMA /
VOCATIONAL SCHOOL |
Executor |
2 |
5 to 8 Years |
Diploma III |
Foreman /
Spr. III |
3 |
9 to 12
Years |
Strata 1 /
Undergraduate |
Supervisor
Spr. II-I |
4 |
13 to 14
Years |
Strata 2 /
Postgraduate |
AVP/S.Md
II-I |
5 |
> 16 Years |
- |
VP / S.Mdy
II-I |
Source:
Data processed 2022.
The table above explains that 3 categories of respondent characteristics
have been obtained in this study. Each category is given a scale that is able
to describe the respondent. The "Last Education" category
characteristic is given a scale of only up to
4. The highest education of all employees at Petrokimia Gresik is a
Postgraduate Master's Degree. Meanwhile, in the "Position" category,
there are those that are higher than Vice President (VP) is SVP (
Senior Vice President ) but during the period of filling
out the questionnaire, not many SVP officials responded.
Table 2. Frequency Statistics
Statistical
Operations |
Years of
service |
Last
education |
Position |
N |
197 |
197 |
197 |
Mean |
2.55 |
2.35 |
2.13 |
Minimum |
1.00 |
1.00 |
1.00 |
Maximum |
5.00 |
5.00 |
4.00 |
Source:
Data processed 2022
The table above gives the average results for the "Period of
Work" category of 2.55, namely in the range 5 to 8 Tadhun. In the
"Last Education" category the average score is 2.35, which is in the Diploma
III range. Meanwhile, the "Position" category gives an average score
of 2.13, namely in the Foreman or Primary Staff III range.
Table 3. Frequency of Respondents' Work Period
Years of
service |
Frequency |
Presentation |
Cumulative |
0 to 4 Years |
23 |
12% |
12% |
5 to 8 Years |
74 |
38% |
49% |
9 to 12
Years |
71 |
36% |
85% |
13 to 14
Years |
26 |
13% |
98% |
> 16
Years |
3 |
2% |
100% |
Total |
197 |
100% |
|
Source:
Data processed 2022
It is known that the frequency of work periods is dominated by employees
with work periods of 5 to 8 years at Petrokimia Gresik. Next, the second
largest are employees with a working period of 9 to 12 years. This explains
that the employees who are the sample to represent the population have
sufficient work experience in their respective fields of work.
Table 4. Frequencies of Respondents'
Last Education
Last
education |
Frequency |
Presentation |
Cumulative |
SMA /
VOCATIONAL SCHOOL |
79 |
40% |
40% |
Diploma III |
25 |
13% |
53% |
Strata 1 /
Undergraduate |
81 |
41% |
94% |
Strata 2 /
Postgraduate |
12 |
6% |
100% |
Total |
197 |
100% |
|
Source:
Data processed 2022
In the table above, it can be concluded that the respondents' education is
controlled by employees with the highest level of education being a Bachelor's
level at 41%, while respondents with a high school/vocational school education
level occupy the second largest educational frequency percentage value, namely
40%. This explains that the level of education at PT Petrokimia Gresik is
relatively high with a strata 1 or undergraduate level.
Table 5. Frequency of Respondents'
Positions
Position |
Frequency |
Presentation |
Cumulative |
Executor |
66 |
34% |
34% |
Foreman /
Primary Staff III |
48 |
24% |
58% |
Supervisor /
Primary Staff II-I |
39 |
20% |
78% |
Assistant Vice
President / Young Staff II-I |
37 |
19% |
96% |
Vice President
/ Middle Staff II-I |
7 |
4% |
100% |
Total |
197 |
100% |
|
Source:
Data processed 2022
Furthermore, the table above explains that the frequency of respondents'
position categories is dominated by Executive level positions at 34%, then the
second largest is Foreman or Primary Staff III level positions at 24%. This
explains that the hierarchy of positions at Petrokimia Gresik is occupied by
employees with positions as executors of work duties who deal directly with
company operations on a daily basis. Meanwhile, in the structural position,
the Foreman is tasked with being a supervisor, organizer and giving
instructions to implementers. In the same position as Foreman , namely
Primary Staff III, included in the functional structure tasked with providing
the results of their work to the Vice President (VP).
Table 7. Frequencies of Respondent Directorates
Company
Directorate |
Amount |
Percentage |
Cumulative |
Main Directorate |
17 |
9% |
9% |
Directorate of Finance and General Affairs |
38 |
19% |
28% |
Directorate of Operations and Production |
140 |
71% |
99% |
DPB Subsidiaries / Projects |
2 |
1% |
100% |
Total |
197 |
100% |
|
Source: Data processed 2022
The table above can be
concluded that the respondents who gave the most responses were from the
Directorate of Operations and Production at 71%. This explains that most of the
respondents are involved in factory operational activities to produce fertilizer within the company.
To see in more detail, each directorate is in charge of several compartment
units which can be seen in the picture below:
Figure 1. Respondent Compartment Unit Statistics
Source: Ms.Form 2022 (Processed Data)
It can be seen based on the
picture above that the respondent statistics based on compartments as work
units are dominated by the Factory Services (JPP) compartment with 35
responses. Furthermore, the second largest was occupied by the Factory II
compartment at Petrokimia Gresik with 18 responses. The Factory Services
compartment contributes to the company through repairs and maintenance of
factory equipment as an important factor in production operations. Then, the
Factory II compartment is tasked with producing processed NPK fertilizer
products and other chemical products.
B. Descriptive Variables
To be able to determine the
level of measurement results for each variable, five strata are used,
including: very high, high, medium, low and very low. Based on the Likert scale
explained in sub 3.6.2 regarding measuring research variables, a value of 5 was obtained for the
highest level and a value of 1 for the lowest level. Next, to obtain the
measurement interval value, use the following equation:
Based on this analysis, categories can be
arranged to form interval levels with the following details:
Table 8. Interval Level Categories Description of Respondents'
Answers
Value
(x) Against Interval |
Category
Level |
1 ≤ x < 1.8 |
Very Low |
1.8 ≤ x < 2.6 |
Low |
2.6 ≤ x < 3.4 |
Currently |
3.4 ≤ x < 4.2 |
Tall |
4.2 ≤ x ≤ 5 |
Very high |
Source: data processed 2022.
In the descriptive section
of this variable, a tabulation of the recapitulation results of filling out the
questionnaire by 197 samples of respondents was carried out.
C. Hypothesis Testing
In the next research,
hypothesis testing was carried out using data analysis techniques applying the Smart
Partial Least Squares (PLS) 3.0 program, which can be seen in more detail
in the PLS 3.
D.
Outer Model Evaluation
Results
analysis Smart PLS with A l gorit h m to test validity and
reliability , coefficients model and Path determination Coefficients for equation models . In evaluating the research measurement
model, one iteration was carried out so that all indicator statements could be
declared valid and maintained. following under.
It can be seen in Figure
4.10 that the quantity indicator (KK2) in the employee performance variable is
measured with 2 statements from the previous one in Figure 4.6 which is
measured with 3 statements. The explanation regarding 1 missing statement, namely
in KK2.1 in the previous iteration, was deleted or removed, because it
was not valid as a measure of quantity indicators in employee performance
variables.
E. Structural Model or Inner Model Test
1) R- Square
The extent to which
endogenous variables are influenced by exogenous factors is measured using the
coefficient of determination (R- Square ). It is possible to determine
whether certain external latent factors have a significant impact on the
endogenous latent variable by examining changes in the R- Square value .
Based on data processing that has been done done through
use Software Smart - PLS 3 .0, obtained R- Square value as following:
Table 9. R- Square
Variable |
R- Square |
R- Square
Adjusted |
Employee
performance |
0.803 |
0.796 |
Source: Data processed 2022
Based on the data
presentation in table 9 above, it can be seen that the R- Square for the
endogenous variable, namely Employee Performance, produces a value of 0.803.
This value can be interpreted to mean that employee performance is influenced
by knowledge Management , Human Resources Competency, and Work
Environment with Innovation as moderation at 80.3%. Of the total 100% variables
that influence employee performance, the remaining 19.7% is obtained where
these variables are influenced by other factors outside the variables tested.
2) F- Square
Square value is useful for finding out whether an
exogenous variable has an influence on an endogenous variable. The following
are the results of the value analysis on F- Square :
Table 10. F- Square Value
Indicator |
F 2 to
Employee
performance |
Information |
Innovation |
0.029 |
Small Effect |
KM-IN |
0.035 |
Small Effect |
KSDM-IN |
0.001 |
N/A |
Knowledge Management |
0.009 |
N/A |
HR Competency |
0.614 |
Large Effect |
LK-IN |
0.014 |
N/A |
Work environment |
0.217 |
Medium Effect |
Source: Algorithm Smart PLS (data
processed, 2022)
Table 10 shows the
Innovation and Knowledge moderating variables Management with
Innovation has a small effect on the Employee Performance variable, then the
work environment variable has a medium effect on the Employee Performance
variable. Lastly, the HR Competency variable has a big influence on the
Employee Performance variable. However, in the moderation of HR Competency with
Innovation, the Knowledge variable Management , and moderation of
the Work Environment with Innovation on the Employee Performance variable have
no effect at all.
3) Collinearity Test
Table 11. Variance Inflation Factor Value
Indicator |
VIF to Employee performance |
Information |
Innovation |
2,311 |
Fulfil |
KM-IN |
1,661 |
Fulfil |
KSDM-IN |
2,093 |
Fulfil |
Knowledge Management |
2,702 |
Fulfil |
HR Competency |
2,416 |
Fulfil |
LK-IN |
2,375 |
Fulfil |
Work environment |
3,454 |
Fulfil |
Source: Smart PLS Algorithm (data processed, 2022)
In collinearity
testing using Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) . The
formative measurement model above shows that all VIF values are no more than 5
for each construct. This explains that the severity of collinearity is still
below the specified threshold.
4) Path Coefficient Test
Path Evaluation The coefficient is
applied to prove the strength of the influence of exogenous variables on
endogenous variables.
Table 12. Path Coefficient
Variable
Formed Constructs |
Path
Coefficient |
Information |
Innovation → Employee Performance |
0.114 |
Influential/Weak Positive |
KM-IN → Employee
Performance |
0.114 |
Influential/Weak Positive |
KSDM-IN → Employee
Performance |
-0.018 |
Influential/Weak Negative |
Knowledge
Management → Employee Performance |
-0.068 |
Influential/Weak Negative |
HR
Competency → Employee Performance |
0.540 |
Influential/Strong Positive |
LK-IN → Employee Performance |
-0.099 |
Influential/Weak Negative |
Work
Environment → Employee Performance |
0.384 |
Influential/Medium Positive |
Source: Algorithm Smart Data
processed in 2022
Based on the overall schema,
the Inner model shown in table 4.24 explains that the Path value
The strongest positive coefficient is shown by the influence of Human
Resource Competency on Employee Performance namely 0.540.
Furthermore, the second largest positive influence is owned by the variable
construct between Work Environment and Employee Performance of 0.384.
Based on the description of
the results themselves, it shows that the variables in the following model have
a Path Coefficient uses positive numbers. The following proves
that the greater the path coefficient value of an exogenous variable relative
to the endogenous variable, the greater the Path value Coefficient means
the strength of the influence of the exogenous variable on the endogenous
variable itself.
5)
Model Goodness Test (Goodness of Fit)
Apart from that, the
Goodness of Fit (GoF) Assessment is then measured via the Root Mean Square Residual (SRMR). SRMR or Root Mean Square Residual is a metric for absolute goodness-of-fit and is
described as the average difference between the observed correlation and the
expected correlation. This is a metric for positive bias and is more biased for
studies with low df and small N. A value of zero indicates
perfect fit because SRMR is a measure of absolute fit. Model complexity is not
penalized in SRMR. In general, values below 0.08 are considered appropriate (Hu
& Bentler, 1999) in
Table 13. Model_Fit
Parameters Model_Fit |
Saturated
Model |
Estimated Model |
SRMR |
0.079 |
0.079 |
Source: Data processed 2022
Based on table 13, the SRMR
result is 0.079, which means that the model construct created in this research
can be said to meet the Fit Model standards and is suitable for use.
6) Direct Effect Test
The next test activity is to
observe the significance value of the influence between variables by observing
the parameter coefficient values and the statistical significance value of T
using the Bootstrapping method
Table 14. T- Statistics and P- Values
No. / Hypothesis |
Variables |
Original
Sample (O) |
T
Statistics (|O/STDEV|) |
P
Values |
|
1 |
H4 |
Innovation → Employee Performance |
0.114 |
1.8 35 |
0.06 7 |
2 |
H1 |
Knowledge Management
→
Employee Performance |
-0.068 |
1 . 00 7 |
0.31 4 |
3 |
H2 |
HR
Competency → Employee Performance |
0.540 |
8.727 |
0,000 |
4 |
H3 |
Work
Environment → Employee Performance |
0.384 |
4.985 |
0,000 |
Source: Data processed 2022
Calculation of the influence
between variables answers the previous hypothesis in sub-chapter 4.2.1 with the
following results:
a) H1: Influence of Knowledge Management (X1) on Employee
Performance (Y)
Based on table 14, test the
Knowledge variable Management (X1) on
Employee performance (Y) gives the original sample result of -0.068
with a negative value
(smaller than 0 and greater or equal to -1), a T-statistic value of 1.007 and has a P- Value 0.314 . Because the T statistic is smaller than
the T table (1.007 < 1.960) and the P- value is greater than (0.314
> 0.05) it means that H0 is accepted which means it has no significant
effect on Knowledge. Management (Z) on employee performance (Y).
b) H2: There is an influence of Human Resource Competency (X2) on Employee
Performance (Y)
Based on table 14, it can be
seen that for the test of the Human Resource Competency variable (X2) on
Employee performance (Y) the original sample result was 0.540 with a positive value (greater than 0 and
smaller or equal to 1), the T-statistic value was 8.727 and has a P- Value 0,000 . Because the T statistic is smaller than
the T table (8.727 > 1.960) and the P- value is smaller than (0.000
< 0.05), it means that H0 is rejected, which means there is a significant
positive influence between Human Resource Competency. (X2) on employee
performance (Y).
c) H3: Effect of Work Environment (X3) on Employee Performance (Y)
Based on table 14, it can be
seen that for the test of the Work Environment variable (X3) on Employee
performance (Y) the original sample result is 0.384 with a positive value (greater than 0 and
less than or equal to 1), the T-statistic value is 4.985 and has P- Value
0,000 . Because the T
statistic is greater than the T table (4.985 > 1.960) and the P- value is
smaller than (0.000 < 0.05), it means that H0 is rejected, which means there
is a significant positive influence between the work environment. (X3)
on employee performance (Y).
d) H4: Effect of Innovation (Z) on Employee Performance (Y)
In table 14, test the
Innovation variable (Z) on employee performance
(Y) gives the original sample result of 0.114 with a positive value (greater than 0 and less
than or equal to 1), a T-statistic value of 1.835 and a P- value of 0.067. because
the T statistic is smaller than the T table (1.835 < 1.960) and the P- value
is greater than 0.05 (0.067 > 0.05), it means that H0 is accepted, which
means that innovation (Z) has no significant effect on employee performance
(Y).
7)
Moderating Effect
Test
Testing the hypothesis of the Moderation effect uses the Resampling
technique method Bootstrapping . An alternative approach for
conducting mediation significance tests (Bollen and Stine, 1990) in
Table 15. Indirect T- Statistics and P- Values
No. / Hypothesis |
Variables |
T Statistics (|O/STDEV|) |
P- Values |
|
1 |
H5 |
KM-IN → Employee
Performance |
2. 107 |
0.03 6 |
2 |
H6 |
KSDM-IN → Employee
Performance |
0.2 35 |
0.8 14 |
3 |
H7 |
LK-IN → Employee
Performance |
1.1 70 |
0.2 43 |
Source: Data processed 2022
Based on table 15, exogenous
variables have a significant influence on moderator variables, and moderator
variables significantly influence endogenous variables. From these results, it can be concluded
that the innovation moderator variable is a half moderator variable .
Partial moderator (half
moderator) occurs when the direct influence of the exogenous variable on
the endogenous variable is significant or insignificant, but the effect becomes
significant or insignificant when the moderator variable is included. Based on
these results, the moderating influence hypothesis was tested in calculating
the path coefficient so that it was known that:
a) H5: Interaction between Knowledge
Management and Innovation in influencing employee performance.
The Effect of Total Knowledge
Management and Innovation (X1-Z) on Employee Performance (Y) obtained a
T statistic of 2.107 and a P- Value of 0.036. Because the T statistic is
greater than the T table (2.107 > 1.960) and the P- value is smaller
than (0.036 < 0.05), it means that H0 is rejected, so there is a significant
influence between Knowledge Management and Innovation (X1-Z) on
Employee Performance (Y).
b) H6: Interaction Between Resource Competencies Human Dan Innovation
in Influencing Employee Performance.
The total influence of Human
Resource Competency and Innovation (X2-Z) on employee performance (Y) obtained
a T statistic of 0.235 and obtained a P- Value of 0.814. Because the T
statistic is greater than the T table (0.235 < 1.960) and the P- value is
greater than (0.814 > 0.05), meaning that H0 is accepted, there is no
significant influence between Human Resource Competency and Innovation (X2-Z)
on employee performance ( Y).
c) H7: Interaction between work environment and innovation in influencing
employee performance.
The total influence of the
Work Environment and Innovation (X3-Z) on employee performance (Y) obtained a T
statistic of 1.170 and obtained a P- Value of 0.243. Because the T
statistic is greater than the T table (1.170 < 1.960) and the P- value is
greater than (0.243 > 0.05), meaning that H0 is accepted, there is no
significant influence between the work environment and work innovation (X3-Z)
on employee performance. (Y).
Discussion
The discussion of this research includes a review
of previous research on the results of the direct effect test and the results
of the moderation effect test on each variable. The results of the study are
then explained theoretically and empirically based on the results of previous
data analysis.
Knowledge Management on Employee Performance
Based on data analysis from the research results
above, it was found that there was no significant influence between Knowledge
Management (Z) on Employee Performance (Y). These results are different
from previous studies such as
Path test Coefficient
table 4.24 Knowledge Management has a negative and weak
influence on employee performance. Petrokimia Gresik have made and
determined policy associated
with management employee through implementation system
Human Capital Based management performance , one of which is Knowledge Management. This research
places Knowledge Management through learning indicators (conversion) to
knowledge application. Application of Knowledge Management by the
organizational development and HR department at Petrokimia Gresik is quite
good, despite the knowledge Management may not be able to have a
direct impact on employee performance without strong work motivation and
commitment from employees to the company. A high level of knowledge does not
guarantee that someone has superior performance if they are reluctant to apply
it. Apart from that, it may be necessary to support driving variables that are
spread outside this research.
Human
Resource Competency on Employee Performance
Based on data analysis from the research results
above, it was found that there is a significant influence between Human
Resource Competency (X2) on Employee Performance (Y). These results are
in line with research
Meanwhile
different results were found
Path test Coefficient
table 4.24 Competency HR has a strong positive effect on employee
performance. Human Resource Competency is closely related to the skills and
abilities of an employee. Figure 1.14 shows that the Petrokimia Gresik company
has employee education at varying levels. Even though high school/vocational
school education is dominated, bachelor's education is the second largest among
all employees . Human Resource
Competence should be improved by companies because it has an influence on
employee performance. Companies can maintain Human Resources
Competency as a Strength in
IS analysis internal and external environment company .
Work
Environment on Employee Performance
Based on data analysis from the research results
above, it was found that there is a significant influence between the work
environment (X3) on Employee Performance (Y). These results are in line
with
Different research results were found by
Path test Coefficient
table 4.24 Work Environment has a moderate positive effect on Employee
Performance. The physical environment can indicate that employees feel
comfortable and safe with the work facilities provided by the company. The
non-physical environment also describes how an employee relates socially with
other subjects such as superiors, subordinates and colleagues. The work
environment at Petrokimia Gresik influences employee performance, so companies
must pay attention to this influence by improving the quality of work
equipment, greening production areas and emissions, as well as setting
harmonious employee communication policies in their work environment.
Innovation
on Employee Performance
Based on the analysis of research data above, a
significant influence was found between Innovation (Z) on Employee Performance
(Y). These results are in line with research
Path test Coefficient
table 4.24 innovation has a positive but weak effect on employee
performance. The Gresik Petrokimia Company is currently intensively cultivating
innovation among its employees as a form of adaptive step in facing various
company challenges. Employees are encouraged to participate in competing their
ideas and creations through holding innovation conventions at compartment
level, company level, and even national level. This should continue to be
encouraged to improve employee performance through employee involvement in
expressing their ideas to support the production process and optimize work
results.
Knowledge
Management and Innovation on Employee Performance
Based on
data analysis from the research results above, it was found that there is a
significant influence between Knowledge Management and Innovation
(X1-Z) on Employee Performance (Y). These results are in line with research
Different research results found
Path test Coefficient
table 4.24 Knowledge Management and Innovation have a weak
positive influence on Employee Performance. Gresik Petrokimia Company
previously showed under Knowledge Management does not directly
influence employee performance. On the moderation of innovation on the
influence of Knowledge Management of employee performance gets
significant results. This can be interpreted as meaning that innovation can
moderate or strengthen the relationship between knowledge management variables
and performance. Companies can consider innovation as a means of applying
knowledge for employees so that employee performance can be maintained and
improved.
Human
Resource Competency and Innovation on Employee Performance
Based on
data analysis from the research results above, it was found that there was no
significant influence between Human Resource Competency and Innovation (X2-Z)
on Employee Performance (Y). These results are in line with research
Path test Coefficient
table 4.24 HR Competency and Innovation have a weak negative influence on
Employee Performance. Innovation does not have a moderating effect on the
relationship between human resource competence and employee performance. This
can happen when an employee's level of human resource competency does not
further encourage an employee who has the Enabler trait to become more
creative and inventive in their work. This means that companies must further
expand innovation as a culture, not only at the employee level with certain
human resource competencies.
Work
Environment and Innovation on Employee Performance
Based on data analysis from the research results
above, it was found that there is no significant influence between the Work
Environment and Work Innovation (X3-Z) on Employee Performance (Y). Different
research results
Path test Coefficient
table 4.24 Work Environment and Innovation have a weak negative influence
on Employee Performance. Innovation at Petrokimia Gresik
as his role moderate work environment towards performance employee gives no
results significant . It means innovation company No capable strengthen
connection Work Environment on Employee Performance . From the research results
This company can consider step alternative other such as increasing Coworking Space with Pantry room
for employees more maximize experience the facilities work and social communication
in increase constructive
atmosphere moment Work .
Based on The discussion has been done in study this , got
it concluded as following : 1. Knowledge Management no influential in a way
direct on Employee Performance . 2. Competence Human Resources
influential in a way direct on Employee Performance . 3. The work environment
has an influence in a way direct on Employee Performance . 4. Innovation is not
influential in a way direct on Employee Performance . 5. There are interaction
positive between Knowledge Management and Internal Innovation affecting
employee performance . 6. Innovation is not can moderate interaction between
Competence Resources on Employee Performance . 7. Innovation Ca n't
moderate interaction between Work Environment on Employee Performance .
Ahdiat , A. (2022, March 22). Indonesia's Food Security Still Loses to Singapore. Databoks.Katadata.Co.Id .
Ajiardani , RLB, & Anjaningrum , WD (2022). How Work Engagement , Innovation Work Behavior , and Physical Work Environment Explaining Employee Performance Vosco Group? Ecogen Journal .
Analisa, LW, & Rahardjo, M. (2011). Analysis Influence Work Motivation and Work Environment on Employee Performance (Study at the Semarang City Industry and Trade Service ).
Annur, CM (2022, July 7). Continuously Increasing , Number RI's population reaches 275.77 million Mid 2022. Databoks.Katadata.Co.Id .
Baird, L., & Meshoulam, I. (1988). Managing Two Fits of Strategic Human Resource Management 2. The Academy of Management Review, 13(1), 116�128.
Bintoro , D., & Daryanto, D. (2017). Employee Performance Appraisal Management . Yogyakarta: Gava Media, 15.
Chin, W. W. (1998). The Partial Least Squares Approach to Structural Equation Modeling. Modern Methods for Business Research, 295(2), 295�336.
Choi, B., Poon, S., & Davis, J. (2008). Effects of Knowledge Management Strategy on Organizational Performance: A Complementarity Theory-Based Approach. Omega, 36(2), 235�251.
Cik, A. (2022). Analysis Determinant Competence On Employee Performance Through Knowledge Management, Job Satisfaction and Innovation at Bank Rakyat Indonesia Pasar Minggu Branch, South Jakarta. repository.unhas.ac.id.
Ciptono , WS (2006). A Sequential Model of Innovation Strategy�Company Non-Financial Performance Links. Gadjah Mada International Journal of Business, 8(2), 137�178.
Cohen, W. M., & Levinthal, D. A. (1990). Absorptive Capacity: A New Perspective On Learning And Innovation. Administrative Science Quarterly, 128�152.
Curana , R., Khomariah , NI, Bagaskara , REA, Mani, L., & Aras, M. (2022). Comparative Study Between the Effect of Television Advertising, Social Media of Instagram, and Brand Image in the Decision of Purchasing New Product. Linguistics and Culture Review, 6(S1), 494�509. https://doi.org/10.21744/lingcure.v6nS1.2067
Desiana , N.E. (2019). Influence Self- Efficacy on Employee Performance Through Innovation As Intervening Variables (Study of the Secretariat and Public Relations Division of PDAM Surya Sembada, Surabaya City). Journal of Management Science .
Diana, R. (2015). Human Resources and Work Productivity . Istinbath Journal XIV,( 15).
Dinantara , MD, & Imron, A. (2021). Influence Training and educational background on employee performance at PT Innovation Global Solusindo in West Jakarta. Journal of Civilization Administration.
Fanulene , CK, Lengkong , VPK, & ... (2022). Analysis Influence Work Environment , Leadership Style , and Work Experience on Employee Performance at PT. Angkasa Pura I (Persero) Sam Ratulangi International Airport Manado. EMBA Journal.
Fauzi, HL (2020). Influence Implementation Environmental Management Accounting and Innovation on Employee Performance at the PT Soy Sauce Factory . Kenari Surabaya. repository.stiemahardhika.ac.id.
Ghoniyah , N. (2011). Improved Employee Performance through Leadership , Work Environment and Commitment . JDM (Journal of Management Dynamics ), 2(2).
Ghozali , I. (2011). Application Multivariate Analysis Using IBM and SPSS Programs. Semarang: BP Diponegoro University .
Ghozali , I. (2016). Application Analysis Multivariate With the IBM SPSS 23 Program ( Edition 8). Printing VIII. Semarang: Diponegoro University Publishing Agency , 96.
Ghozali , I., & Latan, H. (2015). Partial Least Squares Concepts , Techniques and Applications Using the SmartPLS 3.0 Program for Empirical Research . Semarang: UNDIP Publishing Agency .
Gold, A.H., Malhotra, A., & Segars, A.H. (2001). Knowledge Management: An Organizational Capabilities Perspective. Journal of Management Information Systems, 18(1), 185�214.
Haeria , Abduh, T., & Mane, A. A. (2018). Influence Characteristics Individual On Employee Performance at PT PLN (Persero) UP3 North Makassar. Economics Bosowa Journal.
Hair, J.F., Hult, G.T.M., Ringle, C., & Sarstedt, M. (2013). A Primer on Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM). SAGE Publications.
Hair, J.F., Ringle, C.M., & Sarstedt, M. (2011). PLS-SEM: Indeed a Silver Bullet. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, 19(2), 139�152. https://doi.org/10.2753/MTP1069-6679190202
Hair Jr, J.F., Hult, G.T.M., Ringle, C.M., Sarstedt, M., Danks, N.P., & Ray, S. (2021). Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) Using R : A Workbook. Springer Nature.
Hariandja , MTE (2002). Resource management Power man . Grasindo .
Harimu , YE, Pio, RJ, & Tumbel , TM (2021). The Influence of Knowledge Management and Learning Organization on PT Employee Performance . Hasjrat Abadi Manado. Productivity.
Hasan, I. (2013). Research Data Analysis With Statistics / Misbahuddin .
Hasibuan , M. (2014). Basic Management, Definition , and Problems of Mold tenth . Jakarta: Bumi Literacy.
Hasibuan , MSP (2005). Human Resources Management , PT. Bumi Literacy, Jakarta.
Hevesi, G. A. (2005). Standards for Internal Control in New York State Government.
Hood, C., & Lodge, M. (2004). Competency, bureaucracy, and public management reform: A comparative analysis. Governance, 17(3), 313�333.
Ihsanti, E. (2014). Influence Competence Human Resources And Implementation System Accountancy Regional Finance Against Quality of Regional Financial Reports ( Empirical Study on SKPD District Fifty Cities ). Journal of Accounting , 2(3).
Irianto, N. (2021). Influence Compensation , Work Discipline and Work Environment on Employee Performance Process And Control Department Quality of PT Petrokimia Gresik. repository.stiemahardhika.ac.id.
Jannah, M., Wanta, W., & Yuliawati , J. (2022). Influence HR competency in Improving Employee Performance in the Era of Revolution 4.0. Syntax Literate: Indonesian Scientific Journal.
Juliansyah , A., & Cahyono, C. (2022). Influence Implementation Integrated Quality Control On Employee Performance Through Innovation and Quality of Human Resources at PT Perikanan Nusantara Makassar Branch. Indonesian Journal of Business and Management.
Jupri , M. (2022). Influence Development Human Resources, Competency On Performance Mediated by Innovation and Commitment Village Assistance Workers in Jambi Province. Journal of Applied Management Science .
Keith, T. Z. (2019). Multiple Regression And Beyond: An Introduction to Multiple Regression and Structural Equation Modeling. Routledge.
Kenny, D. A. (2015). Measuring Model Fit.
Khasanah , IFN, & Himam , F. (2019). Leadership Transformational Proactive Personality and Work Design as Predictor Innovative Work Behavior . Gadjah Mada Journal of Psychology ( GamaJoP ), 4(2), 143.
Kholis , I., & Setiaji , K. (2020). Analysis Effectiveness Policy Subsidy Fertilizer for Rice Farmers . Economic Educational Analysis Journal, 9(2), 503�515. https://journal.unnes.ac.id/sju/index.php/eeaj
Commission VI. (2021, April 20). PT Pupuk Indonesia Must Fulfill 100 Percent of National Needs . House of Representatives of the Republic of Indonesia.
Kurnianto , D., & Kharisudin , I. (2022). Influence Path Analysis Work Motivation , Work Discipline , Job Satisfaction , Work Environment on Employee Performance with Intervening Variable Organizational Citizenship Behavior. PRISMA, Proceedings of the National Mathematics Seminar .
Kurniawan, RA (2022). Analysis Compensation and Knowledge Management on Employee Performance With Motivation As Intervening Variables at PT Mitra Pratama Mobilindo Yogyakarta. DEWANTARA ECOBIC JOURNAL.
Liebeskind, J. P. (1996). Knowledge, Strategy, And The Theory Of The Firm. Strategic Management Journal, 17(S2), 93�107.
Mangkunegara , AAAP (2011). Resource management Power man company .
Mangkunegara , AAAP (2014). Source Framework Performance Thinking . Gramedia, South Jakarta.
Mardiah , U., & Simatupang , P. (2020). The Influence of Roles and Innovation on Employee Performance at PTPN IV Plantation Unit Come see . Management: Economic Journal.
Mas'Ud, F. (2004). Organizational Diagnostic Survey Concepts and Applications . Diponegoro University Publishing Agency .
Medina, E. (2021). Influence Implementation ISO 9001: 2015 Quality Management System and HR Competency on Employee Performance at PT. Infiniti International Logistics Medan. Collection of Student Scientific Work Faculty of Social Sciences, 1(01).
Mehmetoglu , M., & Venturini, S. (2021). Structural Equation Modeling With Partial Least Squares Using Stata and R. Chapman and Hall/CRC.
Mills, A.M., & Smith, T.A. (2011). Knowledge Management and Organizational Performance: a Decomposed View. Journal of Knowledge Management, 15(1), 156�171.
Mudassir, R. (2022, January 29). Need Fertilizer Subsidized Reaching 25.18 Million Tons, Ministry of Agriculture Only Fulfilled 9.5 Million Tons. Ekonomi.Bisnis.Com.
Mufarrikoh , Z. (2019). Educational Statistics ( Concepts of Sampling and Hypothesis Testing ). Jakad Media Publishing.
Mundovi , D. (2017). Study of PT Petrokimia Gresik's Business Strategy in Order to Increase Competitiveness to Win Business Competition and Responding to Global Challenges . Airlangga University.
Nasution, MN (2005). Integrated Quality Management . Bogor: Ghalia Indonesia.
Nur Adha, R., Qomariah , N., & Hasan Hafidzi , A. (2019). Influence Work Motivation , Work Environment , Work Culture on the Performance of Jember Regency Social Service Employees . Science and Technology Research Journal , 4(No.1).
Nurhayati, N. (2021). Influence Job Placement and Work Innovation on Employee Performance at the Tirta Mangkaluku Drinking Water Company, Palopo City . repository.umpalopo.ac.id.
Petrokimia Gresik. (2021a). Petrokimia Gresik 2021 Sustainability Report � Strengthening Resilience To Improve Growth .�
Petrokimia Gresik. (2021b). Petrokimia Gresik 2021 Annual Report � Strengthening Resilience To Improve Growth .�
Pono, NF, Hadi, S., & Kirana, KC (2022). Analysis Influence Work Discipline and Motivation and Physical Work Environment On Employee Performance Through Ocb at the Yogyakarta Special Region Manpower and Transmigration Service. Journal of Effective Economics .
Primawanti , EP, & Ali, H. (2022). Influence Information Technology , Web -Based Information Systems and Knowledge Management on Employee Performance (Literature Review Executive Support System (ESS) For Business). Economic Journal of Information Systems Management .
Ramadan, AF (2018). Influence Application of Knowledge Management to Employee Performance (Study in the HR Compartment of PT Petrokimia Gresik). repository.ub.ac.id.
Robbins, S. P., & Coulter, M. K. (2018). Management 14E (14th ed.). Pearson Education.
Robbins, S. P., & Judge, T. (2019). Organizational Behavior. Pearson.
Rusdiana , S., & Maesya , A. (2017). Economic Growth and Food Needs in Indonesia. Agrieconomics , 6(1).
Rusdianasari , F., Komariyah , S., & Adenan, M. (2019). Slowdown Growth and Transition Demography in Indonesia. Media Trends, 14(1), 105�119.
Safitri , H., & Anwar, SM (2019). The Influence of Company Resource Innovation on Superiority Compete at PT.Adira Dynamics of Multi Finance Palopo City Branch . STIE Muhammadiyah Palopo Management Journal , 3(2).
Satri , G. (2021). Welcome Gen Z, the Driver of Innovation! Management Forum, 35(2), 1�10.
Sarstedt, M., Ringle, C. M., & Hair, J. F. (2021). Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling. In Handbook of Market Research. Springer.
Sekaran, U., & Bougie, R. (2016). Research methods for business: A skill building approach. John Wiley & Sons.
Setiawan, D. (2019). Application of People CMM for Analysis Workforce Competency in Manufacturing Companies . Industrial Journal Electrical Engineering And Aviation , 8(1).
Setiyowati , H., & Kurniawan, B. (2021). The Influence of Knowledge Management on Garment Employee Performance . British Journal.
Setyanti , SWLH (2017). Strategic Role Human Resources Knowledge Management based in Realizing Good Corporate Governance. National Seminar and Call For Papers on Economics and Business, 434�440.
Setyawan , A. (2018). Analysis of Factors That Influence Employee Performance ( Case Study of Three Offshore Fabrication Companies in Batam and Karimun ). In Journal of Accounting & Management Innovation (Vol. 2, Issue 1).
Sivanissa , N., & Azizah, H. (2022). Influence HR competency towards performance employee at PT Sherish Cipta Interindo . Nautical: Multidisciplinary Scientific Journal.
Sugiyono . (2013). Educational Research Methods Approach Quantitative , Qualitative and R&D. Alphabet .
Sugiyono . (2015a). Combination Research Methods (Mixed Methods). Bandung: Alphabeta , 28, 1�12.
Sugiyono . (2015b). Quantitative , Qualitative , and R&D Research Methods (22nd ed.). Alphabet .
Suharto, R.B. (2022). The Influence of Good Governance and Competence Human Resources and Motivation To Work Commitment and Employee Performance With Innovation as a Moderating Variable . Management Journal.
Sulistyastuti , DR (2017). Indonesia's Challenge to Optimize Bonuses. Journal of Youth Studies, 6(1), 538�547.
Sunarsih , N. (2018). Human Resource Management Based Competency : Improving Strategy Company Competitive Ability . JUARA AKRAB Journal, 3, 17�28.
Suryani, NK, & FoEh , JEHJ (2018). Organizational Performance ( First ). Deepublish .
Susanty, E. (2013). Organizational Climate : Benefits for Organizations . National Semester Fekon : Indonesian Economic Optimism 2013, Between Opportunities and Challenges , 1(2), 230�239.
Syaputra , M. (2017). Influence of Knowledge Management Process On Organizational Performance Mediated by Product Innovation and Process Innovation in Employees Who Work at PT Sinar Sosro in Jakarta. THESIS-2017.
Tejada, J. J., & Punzalan, J. R. B. (2012). On The Misuse of Slovin's Formula. The Philippine Statistician, 61(1), 129�136.
Tripathi, A., & Kalia, P. (2022). Examining the effects of supportive work environment and organizational learning culture on organizational performance in information technology companies: The mediating role of learning agility and organizational innovation. Innovation, 1�21.
Wati Bd, L. (2022). Influence HR Development , Competency , Work Evaluation , and Rewards for PT Karni Jaya Nusantara Employee Performance . repository.univ-tridinanti.ac.id.
Wibowo, D., & Muljono , P. (2021). Analysis Of The Effect Of Knowledge Management, Competency, And Innovation On Employee Performance. Journal of Applied Management (JAM).
www.pupuk-indonesia.com. (2022). Main and Controlling Shareholders Indonesian Fertilizer . Www.Pupuk-Indonesia.Com. https://www.pupuk-indonesia.com/id/pemegang-saham
Yuliyanto , H. (2008). Influence Environment and Motivation to Use of Knowledge. National Conference on Management Research.
Zahra, S.A., & Das, S.R. (1993). Innovation Strategy And Financial Performance in Manufacturing Companies: An Empirical Study. Production and Operations Management, 2(1), 15�37.
Zahra, S.A., & George, G. (2002). Absorptive Capacity: A Review, Reconceptualization, and Extension. Academy of Management Review, 27(2), 185�203.
Zaied, ANH (2012). An Integrated Knowledge Management Capabilities Framework For Assessing Organizational Performance. International Journal of Information Technology and Computer Science, 4(2), 1�10.
Zaied, A.N.H., Hussein, G.S., & Hassan, M.M. (2012). The Role of Knowledge Management in Enhancing Organizational Performance. International Journal of Information Engineering and Electronic Business, 4(5), 27.